The topic
that is very hot around the world today is Facebook IPO filing, with 100 billion dollar valuation.
I ask this
question my self,
- Why should I invest on this stock?
- Is it really Facebook worth for 100 billion, valuation?
This
company is well managed, interesting product, huge customer base and good
revenue for past year.With 843 million users and 48 % of users logging in daily, easily it
will have 400 million visitors daily.With 10
cents income per customers, it can easily earn 4 million dollars daily. The
numbers look very attractive for any investors to buy the share.
The revenue
of the Facebook completely depends upon the user’s interest to login to the
system.
Why any user
should login to Facebook at first place?
The driving factor for the end users
to login to this website is very fragile. I login since all my friends’ login to
the website. No compelling reasons, no atmost benefit for me because of my login.
It is like
a FAD.
Marketing company were utilizing this FAD
How far
the people will be interested in Facebook? what is the risk of losing them ?
It is
unlike Google (take users where they want in web world), Apple (outstanding
product lines) & Microsoft (from Operating systems to different product
line) where they provide something that people or business required for their day to day activities.
This will keep users coming back to them. They have some sustained product line,
on which they can build upon.
Facebook don’t
have a sustained product line. I receive e-mail from Facebook asking me to
login. Most of us would have received if we don’t login the Facebook for a
week.Facebook is
something that is not a necessity, it is something that is always a good to have. The risk for an
investor is when this FAD on Facebook will end.
History had
shown the impact of these fads on AOL, Yahoo, MySpace etc…
Already Facebook is over valued around 100 times the current earnings. Most
of the times all compare Facebook with Google for it's income potential.
The growth
of the Google stocks with an IPO price of 85$ is 700% (Current price is 595$) over
8 years. The market value of Google is 24 billion dollars at IPO and today it is
valued at 154 billion dollars.
With this
equation if you want to get the same return considering 22$ IPO price for
Facebook, the market cap of the company has to grow to 700 billion dollars to
reach a price of 154$ per share.
GE the biggest conglomerate in the world is valued at 200 billion today. So the Face
book has to outgrow the GE. Hope that will happen !!!
All said one should
not forget, Facebook is already having 3 billion dollars in bank and with IPO
it will have around another 10 billion dollars in bank. With 13 billion dollars at it’s
kitty they may venture into another business (as Google entered into mobile
market). That business may be a sustainable business model. This calculation makes
the company a very valuable target.It all depends upon what Facbook do with this 13 billion .
With these
facts, I would say currently the Facebook stock is not as attractive as it is claimed for retail investors. If Facebook can provide a better business model
projection, then the retail investors can validate this stock for a reasonable
price. For naïve retail investors, this stock and the income potential is like
a mirage. Please control the emotion before jumping into.Please do your home work.
For
Institutional investors, they are well informed about this situation, they will
utilise this IPO to make some money.So there will be a rush from institutional investors.
Please be
aware in stock market, "some one has to lose money for some one to gain money"
Retail
investors control your emotion and do your home work before jumping into.
Agree with your analysis. My biggest problem with Facebook is that bit you say about "10 cents per day per customer". To date, I haven't paid Facebook a dime, much less one a day. Nor have I clicked on any of their ads. Despite all the noise made about customized advertising based on interests, I've yet to see any company do a good, or even an average job of it. Instead, I typically get junk mail from companies trying to sell me services I already subscribe to from them. And they want me to think that with more info about me, they'll do a better job?
ReplyDelete